Educational software to Teaching and Learning Pharmacology


Ever since computer systems grew to become out there, they've had a profound influence on society with a digital variety of purposes. Within the academic context the computer systems and its sources are already inserted. It might be a useful gizmo for info searches, information evaluation and storage, and might help present a horny studying setting. Moreover, in science schooling, computer-based studying can be utilized for describing, explaining, and predicting scientific processes. Summary scientific phenomena occurring within the macroscopic or within the microscopic degree will be attractively illustrated and mentioned by computational sources comparable to academic software program. Additionally, academic software program can be utilized to facilitate the training of particular ideas on the mobile and molecular ranges in organic and well being sciences All these Data and Communication Applied sciences (ICTs) are of nice significance as instruments for instructing a number of scientific topics like anatomy and histology in addition to different non-descriptive topics as physiology and pharmacology . Amongst them, pharmacology is a mainstream, primary science within the examine of drugs and different well being programs . Moreover, pharmacology is greater than a definite topic in science schooling; it's an interdisciplinary topic that integrates primary and scientific sciences . Nevertheless, instructing and studying pharmacology is a posh job. College students are anticipated to be taught a big quantity of knowledge by the point that they undergraduate. On this context, researchers has highlighted the necessity to evaluate the instructing practices in pharmacology schooling .

Contemplating these details, an academic software program was developed as a instrument to assist pharmacology lecturers in addition to to advertise an energetic and motivated studying setting to college students. The aim of this examine was due to this fact to judge each the subjective (scholar notion) and goal (scholar examination outcomes) usefulness of this computational instrument. Moreover, some software program traits (navigability, usability, pleasant and others) had been additionally evaluated.

Materials and Strategies

Software program Improvement

The academic pharmacology software program referred to as PHARMAVIRTUA was developed utilizing mixture of Adobe® Director® and Adobe Flash® software program. They're each highly effective, interactive authoring packages.

The software program was distributed in a CD-rom media and its executable file can run each in MACs or PCs machines. Our model was designed to run in a Microsoft Windowsâ setting.

Normally, the pharmacology software program at the moment out there will be categorized into six main classes (E. Hughes, 2002). There are pharmacology Quizzes, digital books, tutorial, simulations, animations and video materials and eventually digital studying environments. These classes usually are not mutually unique in that some software program packages could comprise materials drawn from multiple class because the Pharmavirtua software program. The fundamental pharmacology content material is introduced as tutorial (hypertext and static figures), animations of essential pharmacological phenomena, simulations and a quiz.

The academic and software program traits had been built-in and validated by cross-functional design life cycle software program. For corporations competing in markets characterised by excessive charges of technological change and excessive charges of market change, product improvement cycle time is being acknowledged more and more as an essential supply of aggressive benefit. A significant class of contributors to the discount in product improvement cycle time is efficient cross practical integration with concurrent product improvement processes . Our cross-functional mannequin was modified for academic functions. Every content material module was analyzed each for college students and lecturers who crammed questionnaires with usability and academic points (information not present) Thus, we may present better flexibility in managing design modifications. Moreover, it doubtlessly reduces the necessity for design modifications leading to a diminished rework.

Instructional Facets and closing analysis

The Pharmavirtua software program use was consider in a summer time course supported by the Oswaldo Cruz Institute – FIOCRUZ, Brazil. This course titled “Pharmacology: An Built-in Method” was deliberate to cowl the Fundamental Ideas of Pharmacology (pharmacokinetics and Pharmacodynamics) with an interdisciplinary foundation. The time course load was 45 hours over per week and 5 pharmacology lecturers had been concerned immediately with the course.

Two months earlier than the course, college students of all components of nation may file a participation utility. Throughout this era 78 purposes had been registered and 30 college students had been enrolled to take part to the pharmacology summer time course. Moreover, four listeners had been included to the earlier chosen college students leading to a complete of 34 college students. The most important enrolment standards had been undergraduate college students from organic and well being space, common imply grade > 7.Zero and a subjective curriculum evaluation.

On the first day, all college students carried out an examination with 20 questions containing primary pharmacology topics. Throughout lessons there have been two pedagogical moments; 1. lectures with case-discussions (widespread to all college students) and a couple of. a second deliberate to college students examine the earlier contents mentioned utilizing the software program or utilizing different instruments together with textbooks, their notes or Web content material, besides the software program. These two moments had been equally distributed alongside complete course load. Thus, 4 teams had been created as follows:

PNS – college students with earlier pharmacology expertise (throughout they undergraduate course) with no use of the software program (n=eight)

PS – college students with earlier pharmacology expertise (throughout they undergraduate course) with use of the software program (n=9)

NPNS – college students with no earlier pharmacology expertise with no use of the software program (n=eight)

NPS – college students with no earlier pharmacology expertise with use of the software program (n=9)

Pre- and pos-test

The scholars enrolled on this examine had been evaluated objectively by way of grades obtained in pharmacology exams. They carried out a pre- and pos-test (earlier than and after summer time course). The take a look at contained 20 questions with primary pharmacology matters divided in three cognitive ranges in accordance Anderson and Krathwohl (2001). The identical examination was carried out by all college students earlier than – and a special one had been created and utilized after the summer time course. The assessments had been randomically created from our database containing over 500 questions (pre- and pos-test).

The 20 questions take a look at had been created with three totally different cognitive degree as follows .

Sort 1 questions: Remembering – Learners are capable of recall the definition or which means of pharmacological ideas (6/20 questions).

Sort 2 questions: Understanding – Learners are capable of clarify, paraphrase or exemplify the pharmacological ideas (7/20 questions).

Sort three questions: Making use of – Learners are capable of clear up utility issues based mostly on pharmacological ideas (7/20 questions).

Subjective and qualitative evaluation

A likert’s scale was used to judge the scholars’ notion involving studying traits and the usefulness of the software program as a pedagogical instrument. Moreover, some questions involving usability traits additionally had been collected. The scholars had been requested to strongly agree, agree, neither agree or-disagree, disagree and strongly disagree statements regarding all of those traits above talked about.

As well as person’s opinions, strategies and criticism had been recorded with a purpose to carry out a qualitative evaluation.

Statistical Evaluation

Statistical evaluation and graphs had been carried out utilizing the GraphPad Prism model 5.00 for Home windows, GraphPad Software program, San Diego California USA ( Outcomes had been thought-about important when p<Zero. 05.


Thirty 4 college students take part of our summer time course and had been divided in two main teams (college students who had completed pharmacology of their undergraduate programs and different who had been no enrolled but.) Than, every group was divided in respect to the usage of software program. (See strategies).

All off college students in the intervening time of our summer time course had been formally enrolled in a public Brazilian college from the drugs, pharmacy and biomedical sciences undergraduate programs. There have been 22 females and 12 male college students with an age of 21 ± 2 years outdated. No socio-economic variations had been discovered between teams (information not present).

Goal evaluation (pre- and pos-test)

The target evaluation consisted by pre and pos-test grades and the time spent to finish the exams (after and earlier than summer time course).

The general grades had been elevated after course each in college students of the pharmacology expertise teams (P or NP) with use of software program. The group with expertise in pharmacology with no use of software program didn't present grade enchancment.

Contemplating all questions (with no kind query stratification) use of the software program apparently present higher outcomes on exams efficiency. Alternatively, an enchancment solely may very well be noticed in college students with pharmacology expertise within the group that use software program.

Absolutely the grades had been: 6.eight ± Zero.6 for the pharmacology college students that no use software program (PNS) earlier than course and seven.four ± Zero.9 after course; 5.2 ± 1.Zero for the pharmacology college students that use the software program (PS) earlier than and seven.three ± Zero.5 after; 5.5 ± 1.1 for the scholars with no expertise in pharmacology that no use software program (NPNS) earlier than and 6.eight ± Zero.eight after and four.eight ± 1.2 for college students with no expertise in pharmacology that use the software program (NPS) earlier than and seven.1 ± 1.Zero after pharmacology summer time course.

The questions used on this examine had been divided in three teams in accordance Anderson and Krathwohl (2001). (See strategies) When the scholars’ performances had been analyzed by separated questions a special profile was discovered. For the sort 1 questions (remembering questions) an enchancment was reached in PS and PNS teams. Right here the software program apparently didn't present any impact on grades’ performances (Determine 2.). In any other case, contemplating each kind 2 and three questions (understanding and making use of questions, respectively) we may clearly observe a constructive impact of the usage of software program, since NPS teams confirmed important enhance on its grades (Determine 2.) In truth, the scholars with no pharmacology expertise confirmed higher performances (earlier than and after assessments) in comparison with college students with earlier pharmacology expertise. Even all teams had confirmed higher leads to pos-tests, solely the scholars with no earlier pharmacology expertise that used software program confirmed variations statistically important (Determine 2.).

Moreover, all college students spent much less time to conclude the pos-tests in comparison with the time spent to conclude the pre-tests (Determine three.).

Subjective evaluation (likert’s scale and different qualitative information)


Over the past decade wealth of pharmacology software program had been developed. As an illustration, over 250 software program packages will be obtained from the British Pharmacological Society (BPS; A major quantity additionally will be discovered by way of Web searches, like tutorial Google and so forth.

Equally essential to develop academic pharmacology software program is the necessity for extra rigorous analysis to supply a scientific and pedagogical basis in respect to common contents and its usability. At the moment, most printed articles on academic pharmacology software program have been descriptive accounts reasonably than empirical investigations. New qualitative and quantitative analysis ought to study the influence on the usage of these instruments within the instructing and studying setting.

Software program packages can be utilized in quite a lot of contexts: in tutorial and small group instructing; in lectures; to raised put together college students for sensible work; as a alternative for practicals; to supply choices inside a restricted course

Educating and studying of the pharmacological sciences inside well being science curricula requires a novel, efficient, and holistic strategy to inspire college students to be taught the important aims of this topic.

Equally essential is the necessity for extra rigorous analysis to supply a scientific basis to information future practices in classroom. At the moment, most printed articles on energetic studying have been descriptive accounts reasonably than empirical investigations, many are outdated, both chronologically or methodologically, and a lot of essential conceptual points have by no means been explored. New qualitative and quantitative analysis ought to study methods to boost scholar’s studying kind displays; discover the influence of beforehand ignored, but educationally important, traits of scholars, comparable to gender, totally different studying types, or stage of mental improvement; and be disseminated in journals extensively learn by school.

Pc-based studying is usually considered a instructing technique in its personal proper however in reality it's merely a supply mechanism able to getting used to supply entry to quite a lot of studying aids involving many alternative instructing strategies.

Software program Analysis

The analysis of academic software program ought to embody an evaluation of the interfaces traits regarding mainly to usability and its implications and impacts on instructing and studying setting.


Anderson, L.W., & Krathwohl, D.R. (Eds.). (2001). A taxonomy for Studying, instructing, and assessing: A revision of Bloom’s taxonomy of academic aims. (2 ed.). New York: Allyn & Bacon.

Auzeric, M., Bellemere, J., Conort, O., Roubille, R., Allenet, B., Bedouch, P., . . . Charpiat, B. (2009). [Designing a tool to describe drug interactions and adverse events for learning and clinical routine]. Ann Pharm Fr, 67(6), 433-441. doi: S0003-4509(09)00145-X [pii]


British Pharmacological, Society, & Physiological, Society. (2006). Tackling the necessity to train integrative pharmacology and physiology: issues and methods ahead. Developments Pharmacol.Sci, 27(three), 130-133.

Burford, H. J., Balfour, D. J., & Stevenson, I. H. (1993). Improvement of PharmTest: a novel private computer-mediated instrument for evaluation of pharmacology. J Clin Pharmacol, 33(5), 400-404.

Doucet, M., Vrins, A., & Harvey, D. (2009). Impact of utilizing an viewers response system on studying setting, motivation and long-term retention, throughout case-discussions in a big group of undergraduate veterinary scientific pharmacology college students. Med Educate, 31(12), e570-579. doi: 10.3109/01421590903193539

Faingold, C. L., & Dunaway, G. A. (2002). Educating pharmacology inside a multidisciplinary organ system-based medical curriculum. Naunyn Schmiedebergs Arch.Pharmacol., 366(1), 18-25.

Grey, J. D., Danoff, D., & Shepherd, A. M. (2007). Medical pharmacology schooling: wanting into the long run. Clin.Pharmacol.Ther., 81(2), 305-308.

Hughes, E. (2002). Pc-based studying–an support to profitable instructing of pharmacology? Naunyn Schmiedebergs Arch.Pharmacol., 366(1), 77-82.

Hughes, I. (2002). Employment and employability for pharmacology graduates. Nat.Rev.Drug Discov., 1(10), 833.

Hughes, I. (2003). Educating Pharmacology in 2010–new information, new instruments, new attitudes. Nippon Yakurigaku Zasshi, 122(5), 411-418.

Kwan, C. Y. (2004). Studying of medical pharmacology by way of innovation: a private expertise at McMaster and in Asia. Acta Pharmacol.Sin., 25(9), 1186-1194.

Kwan, Chiu Yin. (2002). Drawback-based studying and instructing of medical pharmacology. Naunyn-Schmiedeberg’s Archives of Pharmacology, 366(1), 10-17. doi: 10.1007/s00210-Zero02-0561-y

Lotsch, J., Kobal, G., & Geisslinger, G. (2004). Programming of a versatile pc simulation to visualise pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic fashions. Int J Clin Pharmacol Ther, 42(1), 15-22.

Lymn, J. S., & Mostyn, A. (2010). Viewers response know-how: participating and empowering non-medical prescribing college students in pharmacology studying. BMC Med Educ, 10, 73. doi: 1472-6920-10-73 [pii]


Manias, E., Bullock, S., & Bennett, R. (1999). A pc-assisted studying program in pharmacology: integrating scientific and nursing information. Contemp Nurse, eight(2), 23-29.

McClean, Phillip, Johnson, Christina, Rogers, Roxanne, Daniels, Lisa, Reber, John, Slator, Brian M., . . . Whitey, Alan. (2005). Molecular and Mobile Biology Animations: Improvement and Impression on Scholar Studying. Cell Biology Schooling, four, 169-179.

Meade, O., Bowskill, D., & Lymn, J. S. (2009). Pharmacology as a overseas language: a preliminary analysis of podcasting as a supplementary studying instrument for non-medical prescribing college students. BMC Med Educ, 9, 74. doi: 1472-6920-9-74 [pii]


Moore, L., Waechter, D., & Aronow, L. (1991). Assessing the effectiveness of computer-assisted instruction in a pharmacology course. Acad Med, 66(four), 194-196.

Morgan, P. J., Cleave-Hogg, D., Desousa, S., & Lam-McCulloch, J. (2006). Making use of concept to follow in undergraduate schooling utilizing excessive constancy simulation. Med Educate, 28(1), e10-15. doi: Okay5356KH755L41X74 [pii]


Novak, J. D. (2003). The promise of latest concepts and new know-how for bettering instructing and studying. Cell Biol Educ, 2(2), 122-132. doi: 10.1187/cbe.02-11-0059

O’Day, D. H. (2006). Animated cell biology: a fast and simple technique for making efficient, high-quality instructing animations. CBE Life Sci Educ, 5(three), 255-263. doi: 5/three/255 [pii]


Ohrn, M. A., van Oostrom, J. H., & van Meurs, W. L. (1997). A comparability of conventional textbook and interactive pc studying of neuromuscular block. Anesth Analg, 84(three), 657-661.

Ortega, A., Pineau, A., Boniffay, J., Benois-Pineau, J., Autret, J. P., & Larousse, C. (2000). [Use of the CD-ROM “Tox-Didact” for teaching of toxicology and pharmacology]. Therapie, 55(1), 203-210.

Patil, Chandragouda R. (2007). Multimedia software program for demonstrating animal experiments in pharmacology. Proc. sixth World Congress on Alternate options & Animal Use within the Life Sciences, 14, four.

Sanger, M. J., & Badger, S. M. (2001). Utilizing computer-based visualization methods to enhance college students’ understanding of molecular polarity and miscibility. Journal of Chemical Schooling, 78(10), 1412-1416.

Sewell, Robert D.E;, Stevens, Robert G., & Lewis, David J.A. . (1996). Pharmacology Experimental Advantages from the Use of Pc-Assisted Studying. American Journal of Pharmaceutical Schooling, 60, 5.

Sherman, J. D., Souder, W. E., & Jenssen, S.A. (2000). Differential Results of Main Types of Cross Useful Integration on Product Improvement Cycle Time. Journal of Product Innovation Administration, 17, 11.

Williamson, V.M., & Abraham, M.R. . (1995). The consequences of pc animation on the particulate psychological fashions of faculty chemistry college students. Journal of Analysis in Science Educating(32), 522-534.

Zlotos, L., Kayne, L., Thompson, I., Kane, Okay. A., & Boyter, A. (2010). An internet-based instrument for instructing pharmacy follow competency. Am J Pharm Educ, 74(2), 27.


Determine 1.

Determine 2.

Determine three.

Determine four.


Desk 1.

Software program/Supply

Intention/Content material