BCJ 3150, Probation and Parole Unit III Case Study – Seventeen year old Marquese
After studying the case, reply the 4 questions listed under. The solutions must be in full sentences and in paragraph type. Every reply must be properly developed and no less than 100 phrases in size. All sources used, together with the textbook, should be referenced; paraphrased and quoted materials will need to have accompanying citations and be listed in APA format.On the high of the web page, please state the title of the case.1. Within the case you chose, was the topic tried as an grownup or as a juvenile? How was the standing decided? Do you agree with this choice? Why, or why not?2. Did the defendant obtain rehabilitation or punishment? Describe their ensuing circumstances intimately. Was their therapy/punishment efficient? What have been the outcomes?three. Given the small print, if you happen to have been the parole officer working the case, what consequence would you've got urged? What particular particulars of the case lead you to this choice?four. In your opinion, (given the small print of the case) was the accused a sufferer of circumstance, or did he make a deliberate option to comply with a felony path? Give particular examples to again your declare.Right here is the article and the hyperlink: https://www.studyproessay.com/write-my-paper/pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/reveals/juvenile/4/marquese.htmlSeventeen 12 months outdated Marquese is what members of the juvenile justice system name a "frequent flyer." He has been out and in of the system for years, and has seven juvenile felony convictions, all theft-related. He has been on probation and hung out in juvenile corridor, on the juvenile camp, and on the California Youth Authority. He was most lately charged with auto theft and residential housebreaking.Due to his repetitive felony conduct, the truth that he was lower than two months in need of being 18, and the truth that he re-offended whereas on parole from the California Youth Authority, prosecutors sought to have Marquese tried in grownup court docket for his newest offenses. At his health listening to, one among his probation officers described him as a "profession felony," who regardless of receiving a number of rehabilitative companies over time continues to interrupt the legislation as quickly as he's launched from detention.Protection Legal professional Gilda Valeros disagrees. She sees him as precisely the kind of child that the juvenile system may assist, primarily due to his character. He's nonetheless very younger emotionally, she says, and really depending on adults for steering and approval. He's very vibrant, and has does properly when he's in an institutional setting: he doesn't trigger hassle, does his college work, and doesn't take part in gang actions. He reoffends when he's launched, she believes, as a result of he isn't given satisfactory assist and supervision. She speculated that, in truth, he could unconsciously be attempting to get caught in an effort to be introduced again into the system, which is the most secure place he has recognized. She mentioned, "It is a very profound factor when you've got such a younger man not likely seeing something in both his fast household or his neighborhood that he can turn into invested in, legitimately and productively and legally. . . . Sadly, probably the most steady environments he ever had have been in establishments."Marquese's mom has severe substance abuse issues, and a few of Marquese's youthful siblings had been quickly faraway from her care by the state. (By the point this occurred, Marquese was already within the juvenile justice system, serving time in services.) She was out and in of jail throughout his childhood, and says that she taught Marquese to steal when he was younger. She advised FRONTLINE that her medicine of alternative have been heroin and crack cocaine. On the health listening to, a probation officer described their house as "a crack home." Regardless of all this, Marquese loves his mom very a lot and could be very protecting of her.At one level, Marquese was paroled from CYA to the custody of his aunt. She was a younger girl in her twenties and had additionally served time within the CYA - for homicide. On the health listening to, Valeros argued that this and different placements have been indicative of how the system had failed Marquese time and again. As a result of he did so properly and was so cooperative with authorities whereas institutionalized, she believes he repeatedly fell by means of the cracks and didn't obtain the help he wanted to reenter society in a productive means.Prosecutors disagreed vehemently along with her characterization of Marquese, claiming that his repeat offending indicated that he was clearly not going to be rehabilitated by one more stint within the juvenile system. His health listening to dragged on over a span of 1 month, one of many longest operating health hearings that anybody concerned may keep in mind.photograph of marquese with others in jail Decide Nancy Hoffman ultimately decided that Marquese ought to get another probability at rehabilitation within the juvenile system. Since he was charged with a nonviolent felony, in an effort to be transferred to the grownup system, Decide Hoffman couldn't discover him unfit based mostly on only one criterion. She may solely ship him to grownup court docket if she discovered him unfit total, weighing all the factors set out by California legislation: the extent of the offender's felony sophistication, whether or not the minor will be rehabilitated inside the time the juvenile system has jurisdiction over her or him, earlier delinquent historical past, the success of prior makes an attempt at rehabilitation, and, lastly, the seriousness of the crime. Hoffman discovered that he was unfit beneath the primary criterion of felony sophistication, since he had deliberate the housebreaking. She additionally discovered him unfit when it comes to his prior report of rehabilitation inside the juvenile system, since he had reoffended so typically after therapy. Nevertheless, she discovered him match beneath the remaining three standards. By way of his prior historical past she discovered that his felony historical past was mitigated by his "horrendous childhood" throughout which he obtained "little or no steering," and was subsequently match beneath that criterion. On the fifth standards, the gravity of the offense, she discovered him match. Due to this fact, Decide Hoffman dominated that he was nonetheless amenable to therapy inside the juvenile system. Marquese was returned to the California Youth Authority and can be up for parole within the fall of 2001.